Shape Shifter |
06-27-2005 05:34 PM |
Law suits and the President
Quote:
Originally posted by Spanky
This is going to cause an explosion, but I think every President from Eisenhower to W., including Clinton, knew what they were doing when it came to foreign policy. The only exception was Carter (and maybe Johnson in the later years of Vietnam). I think almost every decision they made, from the perspective of the time when they made it, made sense. They all made mistakes, but I think the decisions that led to the mistakes were well thought out and just turned out to be wrong. I think they had the countries best interest in mind and were bright practical people. On the other hand, every time Congress has gotten involved in Foreign policy they have just botched it up. They have just done stupid things, that would lead to obvious disasters: Limiting the funds to Korea, cutting off funds to South Vietnam in 1974, cutting off funds to the Contras etc. Therefore, you don't want to hear my answer.
|
I think you underrate Carter. Carter brokered peace between Israel and Egypt that has lasted until the present day, despite the tensions. He seized on an expanded the Nixon/Kissenger concept of hamering the Soviets with Human Rights provisions in treaties, which are largely credited by serious historians in bringing about the downfall of the Soviet empire. He gets shit about the Panama Canal, but I think we've all shown that the Canal is really ours, no matter whose real estate it's on, and that we're more than capable of taking care of business in Panama should push come to shove.
He was played a nasty hand by Iran, and I'm not sure what he could have done differently. Had we invaded, a territorially ambitious Saddam Hussein, funded and armed by the Soviets, would probably have taken advantage of the situation to seize Iran's southern oilfields, and we would have found ourselves in another proxy war.
As for the essence of your post, foreign policy is not efficient when run by committee, and the Executive Branch generally has free reign. However, treaties must be approved by Congress, and Congress controls the pocketbook. Therefore, there needs to be a certain degree of cooperation and trust between the White House and Congress on foreign policy.
|