Quote:
Originally posted by Replaced_Texan
long, complicated Harry Potter speculation
Abstract: In which it is proposed that the basin full of potion that Harry and Dumbledore found in the cave was itself a horcrux, and that the locket lying in the bottom of said basin was merely a red herring, planted there by Dumbledore to prevent Harry realizing what was really going on. It is further proposed that Dumbledore had been aware of this horcrux and its nature for years, and had long ago come to the conclusion that in order to destroy it he would have to drink it, necessitating that someone kill him in order to complete the destruction of said horcrux. It is finally proposed that Dumbledore was keeping Snape in reserve for this very task of killing him, and that in Book Seven Snape will be proven to have been acting solely on Dumbledore's orders with a view to Voldemort's ultimate defeat, and is therefore not guilty of murder or betrayal (in this case, anyway).
|
That's awesome. It would explain (maybe? I couldn't access the full explanation) why the basin had been refilled (I mean, I guess it hadn't been refilled?), because if someone else had drunk the potion to get at the locket and replace it with the phony, where would they get more potion to refill the basin?
