Quote:
Originally Posted by ThurgreedMarshall
What's your list? Mine goes:
1. Lebron
2. Kobe
3. Durant
4. Wade
5. Melo
6. Howard
7. Williams
Everyone else
TM
Eta: I think you need an MJ-type scorer who can completely control a game come game time to be successful (notwithstanding Detroit's recent success). Those guys can draw fouls, score at will and control the game. That's why I don't rank guys like Howard higher.
|
Guess it depends what's the criteria. I usually think about it from a starting/adding to a team perspective, and I'd put Rose, Williams and CP ahead of 'melo. For straight up supa-dupa star power, yeah, your list gets it, tho I'd dispute the "control a game" thing, as your actual rating system as LeBron hasn't really demonstrated he can do it when it really counts and you have Howard hugely overrated by that standard.
Threaded Mode