Ty- now is it a scandal?
 

Are we impregnating or not? I mean, if we can sow our seed (literally) in the country we have taken over . . .

Ty- now is it a scandal?
 

I dont' really see a difference between rape and beating someone senseless. They are both incredibly heinous actions.

Ty- now is it a scandal?
 

Who are we, mere women, to suggest that time-honored traditions such as rape and pillage should be abandoned?

Ty- now is it a scandal?
 

No, you misunderstand me. Innocents should never be beaten.

Ty- now is it a scandal?
 

If a women was known to have killed and had information that would prevent further killing, is raping her not a justifiable way to get the information? I don't see this moral delema (sp?) differently than if we substitute "beating" for "raping".

Ty- now is it a scandal?
 

I know daddy is fighting with the insurgents, but I don't want to give information on him because, well, he's my daddy.

Am I raped or no?

And I'm still curious about your own sweet ass.

And, OK, so, if the insurgents capture an American soldier and he won't give up all the info he knows, it's OK to sodomize him?

Ty- now is it a scandal?
 

No, assumng you are innocent.

I bet you are . . . .

Ty- now is it a scandal?
 

answer the american soldier question, and how am I innocent if i have info that I won't give up?

and can we smash the testicles so as to cause immense pain and, as a side effect, prevent further breeding?

Ty- now is it a scandal?
 

Uh, who, exactly, is determining innocence and non-innocence?

Ty- now is it a scandal?
 

BTW, if you're giving out choices, put me down for "beating."

Ty- now is it a scandal?
 

The rules would apply equally to all sides.

Listen, I said I'm torn. But I find it hard to really draw lines when you are in an absolutely chaotic and possible immoral state of war, where the winner takes all.

I also think that there are utility arguments for the no-holds barred approach, assuming the techniques are actually effective - I've heard different accounts as to that.

Ty- now is it a scandal?
 

This is a hypothetical exercise. Don't bring practicality into it.

Ty- now is it a scandal?
 

So you are backing off? I look forward to films of American soldiers being sodomized.

I don't think it's fair of you to vent your self-hatred -- at what is really a natural curiousity you are feeling -- on those poor soldiers, though. I'm sure you would have no trouble picking up some toys to try things out in the privacy of your own home. Pay cash.

Ty- now is it a scandal?
 

Backing off what.

And if you meant the above as some sort of dig, you should take your homophobia back to where you found it.

Ty- now is it a scandal?
 

You are proposing a rule. You can't ignore the practicalities. By saying "this is just theoretical" you are basically saying "OK, in real life, I'm full of shit and my theory sucks." That would be "backing off."

I would give you the ass toys, if I didn't think that was gross. I think it's good to explore.

ETA my ass toys. I think it would be gross to pass along used ass toys.