| 
		
			| Hank Chinaski | 12-19-2006 09:28 PM |  
 And it's all free!!!!
 
	Quote: 
	
		| Originally posted by Sidd Finch
 I don't know.  Like I said, I hesitate to draw a lot of conclusions from anecdotes -- I was just giving a counter-example to Spanky's anecdote (on which he does seem to base broad conclusions).
 
 Your theory -- that we were a nice extra 50 Euros -- is interesting, but I think it's wrong.  In Paris, they definitely didn't know we were tourists when they sent the doctor.  My wife speaks fluent French.  We were staying in an apartment in a residential area (we did a home exchange).  The doctor thought it was our apartment and was surprised to learn that we didn't live there.  We probably could've faked our way through and not paid, but maybe they require you to show an ID card or something.  In any event -- the dispatcher certainly had no idea, and it's hard to believe that the dispatcher would really make an effort to give some unknown doctor extra cash.
 
 Almost ditto for Avignon.  While we were staying in a hotel, it was during an event where Frogs galore pour into Avignon.
 
 As for the poor people in the rioting suburbs, you are probably right -- though, I would note, the neighborhood where we stayed in Paris was hardly an upper-class area.  In any event, I'm not sure that it makes sense to compare the (unknown) experience of poor Frogs with the anecdotal experience of US lawyers.  Do you think uninsured Americans get the same level of medical care that you get?
 
 |   to the last question- no. And I would be in favor of providing some level to them. I just want to not screw up what we have. I grew up lower middle class. i had good health care.
 
The story I posted was from a Detroit Business magazine. It reports on efforts by Detroit hospitals to market to Canadians disillusioned by their health care. Maybe it is as simple as saying whenever 2 systems are built that cover so much ground, each system will have strengths and weaknesses. Maybe the Canadians that come over here are simply doing so to take advantage of a few loophole areas where we are better, but I've never heard of a US guy going over there for health care*.
 
*except types of lasik are approved more quickly, so people go for that. but that's not insurance covered. |