| sebastian_dangerfield |
03-17-2015 05:14 PM |
Re: Patton (no, not that one)
Quote:
I feel like you're ignoring my response. Satire, mocking, and poking fun through comedy has its place. Agreed. But being able to brush off the every day, real-life impact of actual racism, misogyny, or homophobia without anger, but merely with a joke, can truly only be accomplished by those who don't face the every day, real-life effects. You know, like Patton Oswalt doesn't.
|
I can believe that. I'd like to think many of the targets of bigotry can brush it off, but I doubt anyone can 100% do so.
Quote:
Yes. Everyone can say and do whatever they want. If you offend a large group of people, you can do so. If they want to express their feelings of being offended, they can do so. If you want to tell them to fuck off and refuse to apologize, you can do so. But for each of those stages, there are consequences. You can't just say, the last stage should be tempered somehow.
|
Agreed. Everybody is free to say what he likes if he's willing to take the risk.
Quote:
If you offend enough people so that you're in a position where you need to apologize in order to keep your job or not lose your show because the network values their business, the decision is still yours whether or not to apologize. But just because the stakes are high doesn't change anything. Your decision just must take into account those potential stakes at every stage.
|
Agreed again. However, if the offended party's first move is to try to censor the offending comic or boycott his or her sponsors, in the interest of free speech, the parties screaming for boycotts or firings as a first response should be subjected to extreme ridicule. (This is only as to comedy, of course. A public personality spewing bigoted crap in earnest deserves to be driven into obscurity.)
Too often, the minute a comic or pundit makes some ironic statement which offends, the first reaction is a crowd of internet bandwagon-joiners demanding his or her termination. This is a bad precedent for free speech for many reasons. First, the internet is filled with idiots who just want to feel self-righteous and belong to movements. And TV is filled with personalities seeking to create and exploit such movements, and the sorts who like to join them. The last thing we need to do is have people like Nancy Grace, George Will, or the oped board of HuffPo, and millions of basement dwellers online, screaming for a comic's head every time something potentially offensive is said.
We need to have a group of people who will, when confronted with opportunists, the perpetually offended, and the boycott-addicted, get together and say, in a resounding voice - with the fury and authority of God himself thundering to Moses - "It's a fucking joke. Lighten up, Francis."
|