| bilmore |
03-15-2005 01:18 PM |
Arnold Quiz
Quote:
Originally posted by The Larry Davis Experience
Does this quote:
mean
a. The fact that Arnold raises money from drug companies means he is as beholden to special interests as those he has demonized since the beginning of the recall campaign.
b. Arnold's legislate-by-initiative governing style means that he is always a man of "the people", and thus his donors are by definition not special interests.
c. Arnold's sentence structure could use some work.
Extra Credit:
If your answer is b., please explain how Arnold's donors are not putting a wedge between the legislators and the job they have been sent to Sacramento to do on behalf of "the people".
[Dunno if Arnold is still a topic around here. A quick flip through the last few posts (libertarian quiz, check...Iraq, check...Tom DeLay unethical, check) indicated that it might be.]
|
You make too big of a leap.
The people giving money to Arnold in the belief that it will move their favored legislation forward are, indeed, special interests. But, Arnold chooses how to react to that money.
If he does things for those payors that he wouldn't have done otherwise, specifically because they gave him the money, then you can use the "beholden" word. If, instead, he continues on his merry way, and his payors know that they aren't buying influence with him, but are merely helping continue in power someone who shares some of their legislative vision, where's the debt?
If Arnold does what he would have done, even after getting bucks from someone else who wants Arnold to continue doing what he's been doing, where's the wedge?
|