LawTalkers

LawTalkers (http://www.lawtalkers.com/forums/index.php)
-   The Fashionable (http://www.lawtalkers.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=14)
-   -   Congratulations Slave and Catrin!!! (http://www.lawtalkers.com/forums/showthread.php?t=814)

1436 10-23-2008 04:56 PM

Re: Madonna is 50. Five-oh.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mmmm, Burger (C.J.) (Post 368398)
If you've stated Kid Rock's argument correctly, then he is a socialist, or at least French. If Apple can get music to consumers for a lower cost, then shouldn't they be entitled to profit from those cost savings? If we operated on his principle, then iTunes would never have been developed, since they'd just pass along all their savings to artists.

I saw a picture of him in a scarf with donkeys on it. I don't know if the donkeys, or the scarf, were French, though.

I think that was a fair paraphrase of his argument from the article you posted.

Mmmm, Burger (C.J.) 10-23-2008 05:00 PM

Re: Madonna is 50. Five-oh.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 1436 (Post 368401)
I saw a picture of him in a scarf with donkeys on it. I don't know if the donkeys, or the scarf, were French, though.

That scarf is popular with welfare-staters, I hear.

ThurgreedMarshall 10-23-2008 05:05 PM

Ummm...
 
I've watched this clip many times and I just don't see how it's not the referee tackling the quarterback.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eFhJGPf8j14

TM

pernsky no account 10-23-2008 05:06 PM

Re: Madonna is 50. Five-oh.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Pretty Little Flower (Post 368392)
Good day, fine sir! I've read your post and am as yet uncertain about the nature of the clarification you seek. Do forgive me if seem a bit dim today. I've been reading Billboard.com.

Exactly, Guv'ner! Point well taken and please accept my humblest foregiveness.

New topic, of the worlds are colliding varietale. Scratch that, new querry of a sort. So a client sends me an email today.....let me clarify, in reality the client is a corporation, a quasi-fictional person at law, if you will, and those "persons" don't have opposable thumbs or other accentuating digits to allow them to hit the "send" button to dispurse the email. The source of the email was actually a flesh and blood human employee of the client aka corporate entity. Full disclosure: middle level employee to be exact, and I say this, because I know what you are thinking, that this person, employee, must be the CEO of the client aka corporate entity, given my corner office statii, but, in fairness, out of a sense of social justice and equity, which is what I am all about, on special occassions, for a premium billing rate adjustment, I deal with the hoi polloi ("proles" in Paigowworld, sniff), if you will. Anywhom, in short, as I digress, the email read:

"Last nite, I dreamted that you shaved your head, and the look was off the hizzle. Everyone in the dream loved it."

Two questions:

A. Is this a come on?

II. If so, does the implicit reference to others in the dream indicate group sex could be at hand (and foot, and other apendage)?

Serious advice appreciated!

Replaced_Texan 10-23-2008 05:13 PM

Re: Madonna is 50. Five-oh.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 1436 (Post 368393)
So AC/DC says they want to sell albums, not singles. That seems easy and it makes little sense that iTunes would deny this sort of control to acts that can sell enough to make it worthwhile. Set a bar and grant the power to any who make it over that bar. If the market doesn't want to pay for whole albums then the band suffers too.

But, Kid Rock complains that the royalty is not high enough. He points out that iTunes doesn't have all of the promotional expenses that a normal label does, so the royalty should be more than the royalty from a CD sale. Also a valid point, but nobody else can get his music on my ipod as a impulse purchase. (To be clear, there is no way Kid Rock would ever make it on in any case, but without iTunes it is even more unpossible.)

Both of these issues seem relatively minor. Is Apple really so stubborn that they can't get this sort of shit together?

Well, it also makes little sense that AC/DC wouldn't explore other online avenues. iTunes isn't the only place that you can buy music online. Amazon is pretty competitive and doesn't have the restrictive software. And Radiohead, noted by Sebby to be more album oriented than singles oriented, doesn't sell on iTunes, but their most recent album was released on their website and did really well.

I think AC/DC is just stuck in the past, but they can get away with it because their fans are used to buying CDs.

ThurgreedMarshall 10-23-2008 05:14 PM

Re: Madonna is 50. Five-oh.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mmmm, Burger (C.J.) (Post 368398)
If you've stated Kid Rock's argument correctly, then he is a socialist, or at least French. If Apple can get music to consumers for a lower cost, then shouldn't they be entitled to profit from those cost savings? If we operated on his principle, then iTunes would never have been developed, since they'd just pass along all their savings to artists.

I thought that was called negotiation. You want my product. I know your business model. If you want my product, it will cost you x% of your spread. If you don't want to give up a piece of that spread, you don't get my product.

TM

Pretty Little Flower 10-23-2008 05:16 PM

Re: Madonna is 50. Five-oh.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by pernsky no account (Post 368407)
Exactly, Guv'ner! Point well taken and please accept my humblest foregiveness.

New topic, of the worlds are colliding varietale. Scratch that, new querry of a sort. So a client sends me an email today.....let me clarify, in reality the client is a corporation, a quasi-fictional person at law, if you will, and those "persons" don't have opposable thumbs or other accentuating digits to allow them to hit the "send" button to dispurse the email. The source of the email was actually a flesh and blood human employee of the client aka corporate entity. Full disclosure: middle level employee to be exact, and I say this, because I know what you are thinking, that this person, employee, must be the CEO of the client aka corporate entity, given my corner office statii, but, in fairness, out of a sense of social justice and equity, which is what I am all about, on special occassions, for a premium billing rate adjustment, I deal with the hoi polloi ("proles" in Paigowworld, sniff), if you will. Anywhom, in short, as I digress, the email read:

"Last nite, I dreamted that you shaved your head, and the look was off the hizzle. Everyone in the dream loved it."

Two questions:

A. Is this a come on?

II. If so, does the implicit reference to others in the dream indicate group sex could be at hand (and foot, and other apendage)?

Serious advice appreciated!

No advice, just a prediction - you're gonna be hitting some corporate-entity skinz, old skool style, IYKWIMAITTYD.

Adder 10-23-2008 05:20 PM

Re: Madonna is 50. Five-oh.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 1436 (Post 368393)
Set a bar and grant the power to any who make it over that bar.

Sounds like a recipe for getting sued to me. Both by the acts that don't get over the bar, and by some crusading plaintiffs lawyer who doesn't like bundling.

Mmmm, Burger (C.J.) 10-23-2008 05:21 PM

Re: Ummm...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ThurgreedMarshall (Post 368406)
I've watched this clip many times and I just don't see how it's not the referee tackling the quarterback.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eFhJGPf8j14

TM

Looks like he was trying to get out of the way and trying to protect himself, and bungled the move and knocked over the guy.

Mmmm, Burger (C.J.) 10-23-2008 05:28 PM

Re: Madonna is 50. Five-oh.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ThurgreedMarshall (Post 368411)
I thought that was called negotiation. You want my product. I know your business model. If you want my product, it will cost you x% of your spread. If you don't want to give up a piece of that spread, you don't get my product.

TM

I suppose, but if he knows apple's business model, then he knows that apple's model is that it has a deal and it doesn't cut special deals (at least not for Kid Rock). Kid Rock's position seems to be "because they're making a bigger spread, they should share some with me and everyone else." If you want to call that a negotiating position, go ahead.

ThurgreedMarshall 10-23-2008 05:37 PM

Re: Madonna is 50. Five-oh.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mmmm, Burger (C.J.) (Post 368421)
I suppose, but if he knows apple's business model, then he knows that apple's model is that it has a deal and it doesn't cut special deals (at least not for Kid Rock). Kid Rock's position seems to be "because they're making a bigger spread, they should share some with me and everyone else." If you want to call that a negotiating position, go ahead.

I'll do that. You go ahead and call him a socialist. Makes much more sense since I'm sure Kid Rock wouldn't agree to give them access to his music if Apple agreed to pay him a piece without making the same deal for every other artist.

TM

pernsky no account 10-23-2008 05:37 PM

Re: Madonna is 50. Five-oh.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Pretty Little Flower (Post 368413)
No advice, just a prediction - you're gonna be hitting some corporate-entity skinz, old skool style, IYKWIMAITTYD.

I do. Righteous!

I'd hi-5 you, if we were more proximate......cyber hi5?

Pretty Little Flower 10-23-2008 05:40 PM

Re: Madonna is 50. Five-oh.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by pernsky no account (Post 368425)
I do. Righteous!

I'd hi-5 you, if we were more proximate......cyber hi5?

ch-5, indeed. Word!

Mmmm, Burger (C.J.) 10-23-2008 05:42 PM

Re: Madonna is 50. Five-oh.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ThurgreedMarshall (Post 368424)
Makes much more sense since I'm sure Kid Rock wouldn't agree to give them access to his music if Apple agreed to pay him a piece without making the same deal for every other artist.

TM

Maybe he would, and then he'd be selling himself out for the principles he purports to be taking a stand on. His (or your) choice.

ThurgreedMarshall 10-23-2008 06:02 PM

Re: Madonna is 50. Five-oh.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mmmm, Burger (C.J.) (Post 368427)
Maybe he would, and then he'd be selling himself out for the principles he purports to be taking a stand on. His (or your) choice.

Kid Rock's boycott is quite clearly an effort to put pressure on Apple to pay him more money based on their business model. If it works and he gets more money, he's a sell-out (not a smart negotiator). If it doesn't, he's a socialist trying to force Apple to give up their profit margins. Ridiculous.

How is this any different than Walmart's negotiations with Sony to sell TVs? If Sony says, "Since you want so many tvs because you're in such a unique position, we'll sell to you for $x," and Walmart says, "This is true. And because we do, you'll sell to us for $y," and Sony says, "Uh, no. If we sell to you for $y, you're making more than we think you should and we want a cut of that margin." It's a negotiation and the price is set based on what is acceptable to both parties or there's no deal. Same shit.

TM

pernsky no account 10-23-2008 06:03 PM

Re: Madonna is 50. Five-oh.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Pretty Little Flower (Post 368426)
ch-5, indeed. Word!


Word, indeed! It's bourne!

Seriously though, Monsieur Fleur,

Prior to my attentions turning entirely to the shaving of my head in preparation for "client contact", I just wanted to say a heartfelt thanks. It has been an incredible day. A true beginning to what may amount to a life changing event for me or at the least, a decent one-nighter (or at the leastest a so-so nothing-special one-nighter, but good enough that's it better than sitting home and watching Bravo all night and fantasizing that I could one day meet Jonathan Adler, somehow, and he would decorate my pied-a-terre, at a discount, and we would celebrate with some tea and scones and clotting cream). Anywhom, merci beaucoup for your spot on analysis, kind words and encouragement.

Also, to RT and the whole lot of you buggers, molto grazie for letting me drop by your chit-chat board and share intimate details of my quasi-professional life.

I am truly feeling the love. And I know, "love" sounds like a strong term, but, in reality it has so many nuances and stratifications. I mean it's really positive and affirming but also has grey areas, and perhaps is separated from hate by a thin line. But, notwithstanding that, let's add new connotation to love, the Lawtalkin' Love. As the imitation sock of one of the original posters on the penultimate progenitor of this Board, I declare this new variant of love, because I can. Its my prerogative.

There it is. Peace. Out.

pernsky no account 10-23-2008 06:06 PM

Re: Madonna is 50. Five-oh.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ThurgreedMarshall (Post 368435)
Kid Rock's boycott is quite clearly an effort to put pressure on Apple to pay him more money based on their business model. If it works and he gets more money, he's a sell-out (not a smart negotiator). If it doesn't, he's a socialist trying to force Apple to give up their profit margins. Ridiculous.

How is this any different than Walmart's negotiations with Sony to sell TVs? If Sony says, "Since you want so many tvs because you're in such a unique position, we'll sell to you for $x," and Walmart says, "This is true. And because we do, you'll sell to us for $y," and Sony says, "Uh, no. If we sell to you for $y, you're making more than we think you should and we want a cut of that margin." It's a negotiation and the price is set based on what is acceptable to both parties or there's no deal. Same shit.

TM

Sirs,

I have read this thread and want to weigh in with an endoursement of Thurgreed on this one. I wikipedia'd "socialism" and, as I suspected, it requires some government involvement in the process.

The negotiations in question sound more like a marketplace give and take, capitalism, perhaps, if you will.

Replaced_Texan 10-23-2008 06:10 PM

Re: Madonna is 50. Five-oh.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by greatwhitenorthchick (Post 368353)
Awesome!

Plus, you get a free Dr Pepper
Quote:

Soft drink manufacturer Dr Pepper, which this past spring offered to send a free can of the beverage to "everyone in America" (excluding ex-GN'R members Slash and Buckethead) if GUNS N' ROSES' new album, "Chinese Democracy", were to arrive anytime during the calendar year 2008, has revealed details of the plan.

"We never thought this day would come," says Dr Pepper VP of marketing Tony Jacobs. "But now that it's here all we can say is: The Dr Pepper's on us."

According to Billboard.com, interested fans are being asked to visit DrPepper.com on November 23, the day "Chinese Democracy" is released in the U.S. exclusively via Best Buy. After registering online, fans will receive a coupon redeemable for a 20-oz. Dr Pepper wherever the drink is sold.

The twist: the coupon is only available for 24 hours and will expire on February 28.

"Chinese Democracy" has been in the works since the mid-'90s, with speculation and mystery surrounding the album's 13-year journey, ever-changing roster of players and spiraling recording costs.

catrin_darcy 10-23-2008 06:13 PM

Re: Madonna is 50. Five-oh.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Replaced_Texan (Post 368410)
Well, it also makes little sense that AC/DC wouldn't explore other online avenues. iTunes isn't the only place that you can buy music online. Amazon is pretty competitive and doesn't have the restrictive software. And Radiohead, noted by Sebby to be more album oriented than singles oriented, doesn't sell on iTunes, but their most recent album was released on their website and did really well.

I think AC/DC is just stuck in the past, but they can get away with it because their fans are used to buying CDs.

It sounds like they are exploring other avenues -- you can buy Black Ice on AC/DC's own website without having to set foot in a Wal-Mart:
http://www.acdc.com/index_album.html

Thanks everyone for the well-wishes! If Slave and I can just make it through the next 13 days, this marriage thing may work out . . . .

Pretty Little Flower 10-23-2008 06:22 PM

Re: Madonna is 50. Five-oh.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by pernsky no account (Post 368436)
Word, indeed! It's bourne!

Seriously though, Monsieur Fleur,

Prior to my attentions turning entirely to the shaving of my head in preparation for "client contact", I just wanted to say a heartfelt thanks. It has been an incredible day. A true beginning to what may amount to a life changing event for me or at the least, a decent one-nighter (or at the leastest a so-so nothing-special one-nighter, but good enough that's it better than sitting home and watching Bravo all night and fantasizing that I could one day meet Jonathan Adler, somehow, and he would decorate my pied-a-terre, at a discount, and we would celebrate with some tea and scones and clotting cream). Anywhom, merci beaucoup for your spot on analysis, kind words and encouragement.

Also, to RT and the whole lot of you buggers, molto grazie for letting me drop by your chit-chat board and share intimate details of my quasi-professional life.

I am truly feeling the love. And I know, "love" sounds like a strong term, but, in reality it has so many nuances and stratifications. I mean it's really positive and affirming but also has grey areas, and perhaps is separated from hate by a thin line. But, notwithstanding that, let's add new connotation to love, the Lawtalkin' Love. As the imitation sock of one of the original posters on the penultimate progenitor of this Board, I declare this new variant of love, because I can. Its my prerogative.

There it is. Peace. Out.

And a fine imitation, indeed, if I may say so, and I believe I may. Spot on.

Good luck with your Tete Rase caper. Don't forget to report back all the gory details! ;)

P. O.

sebastian_dangerfield 10-23-2008 06:28 PM

Re: Madonna is 50. Five-oh.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Replaced_Texan (Post 368410)
Well, it also makes little sense that AC/DC wouldn't explore other online avenues. iTunes isn't the only place that you can buy music online. Amazon is pretty competitive and doesn't have the restrictive software. And Radiohead, noted by Sebby to be more album oriented than singles oriented, doesn't sell on iTunes, but their most recent album was released on their website and did really well.

I think AC/DC is just stuck in the past, but they can get away with it because their fans are used to buying CDs.

AC/DC gets away with it for the same reason the Beatles do it. Because they can.

AC/DC sells over a million records a year even when they don't do a new album. They're one of the top selling bands in the world and they make staggering cash by forcing fans to buy whole cds on the pretext that they want their albums to be bought as "whole items." Bullshit. AC/DC is a singles group if there ever was one. They know if they went on Itunes their records would be cannibalized the same way people buy the one or two decent Stones' songs from that band's lamentable 70s and 80s releases.

If AC/DC went online people would only buy the hits and the band would lose money. So they don't. It's just smart business.

1436 10-23-2008 06:43 PM

Re: Madonna is 50. Five-oh.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by sebastian_dangerfield (Post 368442)
AC/DC gets away with it for the same reason the Beatles do it. Because they can.

AC/DC sells over a million records a year even when they don't do a new album. They're one of the top selling bands in the world and they make staggering cash by forcing fans to buy whole cds on the pretext that they want their albums to be bought as "whole items." Bullshit. AC/DC is a singles group if there ever was one. They know if they went on Itunes their records would be cannibalized the same way people buy the one or two decent Stones' songs from that band's lamentable 70s and 80s releases.

If AC/DC went online people would only buy the hits and the band would lose money. So they don't. It's just smart business.

And I suppose Apple has decided that it would rather not sell AC/DC than have to deal with the backlash of letting one band dictate terms.

It is all just business, but now I have to drive home without AC/DC's new album instead of with.

Sucks.

Hank Chinaski 10-23-2008 06:46 PM

Re: Madonna is 50. Five-oh.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by pernsky no account (Post 368407)
Exactly, Guv'ner! Point well taken and please accept my humblest foregiveness.

New topic, of the worlds are colliding varietale. Scratch that, new querry of a sort. So a client sends me an email today.....let me clarify, in reality the client is a corporation, a quasi-fictional person at law, if you will, and those "persons" don't have opposable thumbs or other accentuating digits to allow them to hit the "send" button to dispurse the email. The source of the email was actually a flesh and blood human employee of the client aka corporate entity. Full disclosure: middle level employee to be exact, and I say this, because I know what you are thinking, that this person, employee, must be the CEO of the client aka corporate entity, given my corner office statii, but, in fairness, out of a sense of social justice and equity, which is what I am all about, on special occassions, for a premium billing rate adjustment, I deal with the hoi polloi ("proles" in Paigowworld, sniff), if you will. Anywhom, in short, as I digress, the email read:

"Last nite, I dreamted that you shaved your head, and the look was off the hizzle. Everyone in the dream loved it."

Two questions:

A. Is this a come on?

II. If so, does the implicit reference to others in the dream indicate group sex could be at hand (and foot, and other apendage)?

Serious advice appreciated!

not to be a timmy, but one does not need opposable thumbs to send email. emakl can be sent equally well after a thumb-ectomy.

however, a lack of thumb will limit the sex acts em can perform.

Replaced_Texan 10-23-2008 06:46 PM

Re: Madonna is 50. Five-oh.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by sebastian_dangerfield (Post 368442)
AC/DC gets away with it for the same reason the Beatles do it. Because they can.

AC/DC sells over a million records a year even when they don't do a new album. They're one of the top selling bands in the world and they make staggering cash by forcing fans to buy whole cds on the pretext that they want their albums to be bought as "whole items." Bullshit. AC/DC is a singles group if there ever was one. They know if they went on Itunes their records would be cannibalized the same way people buy the one or two decent Stones' songs from that band's lamentable 70s and 80s releases.

If AC/DC went online people would only buy the hits and the band would lose money. So they don't. It's just smart business.

Again, they could sell the whole album online without having the songs piecemealed out on their own website or one of iTune's competitors.

sebastian_dangerfield 10-23-2008 06:48 PM

Re: Madonna is 50. Five-oh.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Replaced_Texan (Post 368439)
Plus, you get a free Dr Pepper

There is no way Chinese Democracy cannot be a let down. The band hit the ball so far with its first three records I can't imagine any way they could put out a better song selection. Say what you will about the band, "Appetite" is one of the best hard rock records of all time. And the "Use Your Illusion" records have some songs that rival the best of Jagger/Richards. The only problem with all of these records is they are horribly overproduced. If G&R stripped the production down and went for an "Exile on Main Stream" sound, tunes like "14 Years," "Dead Horse" and "Yesterdays" would be all time rock radio classics. They're every bit as well crafted as classics like "Tumbling Dice."

sebastian_dangerfield 10-23-2008 06:52 PM

Re: Madonna is 50. Five-oh.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Replaced_Texan (Post 368448)
Again, they could sell the whole album online without having the songs piecemealed out on their own website or one of iTune's competitors.

That's baffling to me. I can only assume they got a killer deal with Wal Mart or the mragin on selling whole cds on Itunes isn't as good as it is selling actual cds.

It's kind of odd for these guys to be greedy, really. They've got more money than God.

I rather enjoyed my trip to Wal Mart, by the way. It's huge and there's tons of stuff to see. The television selection was impressive.

sebastian_dangerfield 10-23-2008 06:55 PM

Re: Madonna is 50. Five-oh.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 1436 (Post 368446)
And I suppose Apple has decided that it would rather not sell AC/DC than have to deal with the backlash of letting one band dictate terms.

It is all just business, but now I have to drive home without AC/DC's new album instead of with.

Sucks.

There's a song in the middle that sounds like Creedence. Shocked me a bit. Then I thought, "Who better to screech like Fogerty than Brian Johnson?" They might be the only two voices in rock who have a high and low range and absolutely nothing in the middle.

By the way, that Fogerty disc you can buy in Starbucks... Buy it. It's really, really good.

Atticus Grinch 10-23-2008 07:33 PM

Re: Madonna is 50. Five-oh.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 1436 (Post 368393)
Both of these issues seem relatively minor. Is Apple really so stubborn that they can't get this sort of shit together?

The iTunes Music Store doesn't exist to make money selling music. It exists in order to continue making Apple hardware necessary in people's lives. The DRM makes it absolutely necessary that your next MP3 player is an iPod. I'm not going to shit-can 4,000 songs for which I paid good money because SanDisk makes a slightly better player this year.

The artists are pissed because Apple isn't incentivized to make money per transaction like they are. Sure, Apple could charge a buck-fitty for Kid Rock's latest excretion, but that won't sell any more iPods, so why risk pissing off the hardware customer base just to make another four cents a song?

ETA and that's why Apple introduced iTunes Plus with premium pricing, only to return to 99 cents either with DRM or without. It's no longer necessary for all the songs to be DRMed -- just enough in everyone's libraries that you wouldn't even think to buy a Sansa because some indefinitely large portion of your music library would be unplayable. Apple has achieved the goal of making the other guy's hardware seem like too much of a pain in the ass. You could offer Sansas and Zunes at cost, and Apple will still sell more iPods.

pernsky no account 10-23-2008 07:39 PM

Re: Madonna is 50. Five-oh.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hank Chinaski (Post 368447)
not to be a timmy, but one does not need opposable thumbs to send email. emakl can be sent equally well after a thumb-ectomy.
.

Off a blackberry? its all i use these days.

Not Bob 10-23-2008 07:42 PM

What's happening all over? I'll tell you what's happening all over.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by taxwonk (Post 368346)
You handled this post quite nicely, nicely, thank you.

Ah, Wonk, I love you like the dope-addled, Zeppelin-addicted older brother I never ha . . uh, Not Nick? Is that you?

eta: I hit 4500 while wonking a wonk post? Jesus H. Christ on a popsicle stick!

Mmmm, Burger (C.J.) 10-23-2008 08:42 PM

Re: Madonna is 50. Five-oh.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ThurgreedMarshall (Post 368435)

How is this any different than Walmart's negotiations with Sony to sell TVs? If Sony says, "Since you want so many tvs because you're in such a unique position, we'll sell to you for $x," and Walmart says, "This is true. And because we do, you'll sell to us for $y," and Sony says, "Uh, no. If we sell to you for $y, you're making more than we think you should and we want a cut of that margin." It's a negotiation and the price is set based on what is acceptable to both parties or there's no deal. Same shit.

TM

What's different is Kid Rock isn't simply saying that Apple's getting too much of the pie from him. He's saying that everyone else should get more of the pie too, and until they do he's not going to sell to them (this, even though a whole bunch of other musicians apparently are satisfied with their piece of pie).

So in your hypo, Sony would be saying "We think you're getting too good a deal from everyone you deal with--Panasonic, Alpo, Hanes, whoever--so we're not going to sell to you at the price you want. In fact, we resent the fact that you're doing that so successfully, so we're not going to sell to you at all." Sure, that's negotiation, but then so would be "I'm going to burn down your store if you don't give me the deal you want."

Mmmm, Burger (C.J.) 10-23-2008 08:49 PM

Re: Madonna is 50. Five-oh.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Atticus Grinch (Post 368452)
Apple has achieved the goal of making the other guy's hardware seem like too much of a pain in the ass.

While I won't quibble with your analysis, I think it is equally fair to say that the other guys, for the most part, did an even better job of making their hardware seem like too much of a pain in the ass.

pernsky no account 10-23-2008 08:50 PM

Re: Madonna is 50. Five-oh.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mmmm, Burger (C.J.) (Post 368456)
Sure, that's negotiation, but then so would be "I'm going to burn down your store if you don't give me the deal you want."

And at that point the State probably comes in and effects some resolutions that, for better or worse, distort the normal give and take in the marketplace. Is that the socialism aspect you were referencing?

Icky Thump 10-23-2008 08:53 PM

Re: Madonna is 50. Five-oh.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mmmm, Burger (C.J.) (Post 368459)
While I won't quibble with your analysis, I think it is equally fair to say that the other guys, for the most part, did an even better job of making their hardware seem like too much of a pain in the ass.

True. I had one of the old brick mp3 players -- the sonic rio. Made me pull my hair out.

In contrast, when I first tried an ipod, I was ready to suck Steve Jobs' dick.

Tyrone Slothrop 10-23-2008 09:22 PM

Re: Madonna is 50. Five-oh.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Atticus Grinch (Post 368452)
The iTunes Music Store doesn't exist to make money selling music. It exists in order to continue making Apple hardware necessary in people's lives. The DRM makes it absolutely necessary that your next MP3 player is an iPod. I'm not going to shit-can 4,000 songs for which I paid good money because SanDisk makes a slightly better player this year.

The artists are pissed because Apple isn't incentivized to make money per transaction like they are. Sure, Apple could charge a buck-fitty for Kid Rock's latest excretion, but that won't sell any more iPods, so why risk pissing off the hardware customer base just to make another four cents a song?

ETA and that's why Apple introduced iTunes Plus with premium pricing, only to return to 99 cents either with DRM or without. It's no longer necessary for all the songs to be DRMed -- just enough in everyone's libraries that you wouldn't even think to buy a Sansa because some indefinitely large portion of your music library would be unplayable. Apple has achieved the goal of making the other guy's hardware seem like too much of a pain in the ass. You could offer Sansas and Zunes at cost, and Apple will still sell more iPods.

Not me! Almost all my music is ripped from my own CDs. And a fat lot of good it does me, since everyone else is completely fucked by Apple's DRM.

Mmmm, Burger (C.J.) 10-23-2008 09:27 PM

Re: Madonna is 50. Five-oh.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Tyrone Slothrop (Post 368466)
Not me! Almost all my music is ripped from my own CDs. And a fat lot of good it does me, since everyone else is completely fucked by Apple's DRM.

Untrue. Icky's got a Rio he'll sell you cheap. Win-win.

Mmmm, Burger (C.J.) 10-23-2008 09:41 PM

Re: Madonna is 50. Five-oh.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by pernsky no account (Post 368460)
And at that point the State probably comes in and effects some resolutions that, for better or worse, distort the normal give and take in the marketplace. Is that the socialism aspect you were referencing?

Well, Kid's not getting anything done on his own (other than advocating for Napster). So I'm not sure which he wants--the government to intervene or for all the other musicians to join him and get an exemption from the antitrust laws for a group boycott.

Tyrone Slothrop 10-23-2008 09:45 PM

Re: Madonna is 50. Five-oh.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mmmm, Burger (C.J.) (Post 368468)
Untrue. Icky's got a Rio he'll sell you cheap. Win-win.

Not to hear him talk.

taxwonk 10-23-2008 10:37 PM

Re: What's happening all over? I'll tell you what's happening all over.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Not Bob (Post 368454)
Ah, Wonk, I love you like the dope-addled, Zeppelin-addicted older brother I never ha . . uh, Not Nick? Is that you?

eta: I hit 4500 while wonking a wonk post? Jesus H. Christ on a popsicle stick!

Dope-addled, yes. Zeppelin-addicted, no way. I like Zep for about 1 week in HS and then had no use for them until I turned about 40. It's only in the last few years that I've come to appreciate that their whole catalog wasn't utter shit. They did have some great songs. They just buried them in so much dreck the gems got lost.

Atticus Grinch 10-23-2008 11:41 PM

Re: Congratulations Slave and Catrin!!!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by taxwonk (Post 368345)
I don't remember the question, but I'd be curious to know what the answer is.

My question related to Betty's motivation to arrange a lunch with Sarah Beth and Arthur and then not to show up. My three hypotheses were (1) Betty wanted to make Sarah Beth feel attractive and was trying to do something nice; (2) Betty wanted to see if she could use a man's attraction to her to manipulate him, but she had no interest beyond seeing if she could yank Arthur's chain; or (3) she was in such pain over Don that she wanted to make Sarah Beth feel miserable by inducing her to succumb to tempation with Arthur so that she wouldn't be the only one with a broken home.

That was an open question until the last episode. SPOILER ALERT. What we learned in the Mountain King episode was that it was 3, with a bit of scientific curiosity about Why People Cheat. I interpret her phone call with Sarah Beth to mean she wanted to find out whether people cheat on nice spouses that they love, and the answer she got was yes. And that cheaters suffer too, which is what she needs to know to forgive Don -- at the expense of her own innocence.

ETA that the story arc is The Great Gatsby reset in Midcentury Modern and with Peggy playing the Sam Waterston character. Which is nice because it's never been well adapted for the screen, but bad because it means Don Will Have To Die.


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 08:24 PM.

Powered by: vBulletin, Copyright ©2000 - 2008, Jelsoft Enterprises Limited.
Hosted By: URLJet.com