| 
		
			| sebastian_dangerfield | 01-10-2015 11:52 AM |  
 Re: Is Ted Cruz Satan? Discuss.
 
	Quote: 
	
		| 
 
					Originally Posted by Tyrone Slothrop
					(Post 492931)
				 Someone (Hank?) asked me what is to be done.  I think this piece is excellent , including this part:
 
Which I guess is quite a bit of it.
 |  2. The economic underpinnings of this can't be denied.  Radical Islam is the direction for the directionless.  
 
But this forces another question.  Why is it Islam?  Why not other religions?  This leads to a problem with the fundamental structure of Islam.  Unlike almost all others today, only Islam retains the proposition it is superior to, rather than merely apart from, the state.  It is the only religion remaining politically involved in not only impacting policy, but in the demand it be directly involved in governing.  
 
This works in Indonesia and Iran, where Islam and the state have found an uneasy detante.  It does not work well in an extremely secularist society like France.  Hence, when the disaffected look for an outlet that attacks the state around them which mires them in segregated poverty, it's inevitably Islam.  
 
Islam needs to have a Second Vatican counsel in which it definitely rejects: (1) Jihad; and (2) Its directives that states must conform to Islam, and, that non-adherents be converted.  Until it does so, its radical variants will remain magnets for angry losers like these Charlies Hebdo assassins.  
 
Catholicism learned to play nice with the nation state structure.  It took a while, but it got there.  Judaism has always been largely cooperative, and Hinduism, despite being politically involved early on, has for centuries recognized the religion/state division.  Islam can get there.  But we need to start talking about it doing so on a more aggressive timetable.  Its extended adolescence is getting a bit trying.  
 
(Of course, we could all grow the fuck up and stop arguing about whose man in the sky is right, which would remove attractive nuisance ideologies like Radical Islam... But this is, sadly, asking too much of the average superstitious, frightened animal man remains.) |