Quote:
Originally Posted by Tyrone Slothrop
I'm sorry I bashed you. I think I speak for the entire board when I say that it would have been entertaining and edifying to see you attempt a constitutional attack on the individual mandate. But discretion is the better part of valor, and I can well understood why you would rather just keep ducking the question.
|
I don't usually reply to the same post twice, but given that all of you have said that Scalia could have no valid way to justify it, and given that you've all said that only politics gave rise to the challenge, any Circuit Court decision that has killed the law AND the only reason there is any possibility any of the Supremes is even considering killing it, what possible reason would anyone have for engaging you?
But, here, I'll tell you what Scalia can do, accepting all of your biases i list above: Scalia can over rule that tiny part of whatever decision you feel limits him here. And of course he will, because he is solely motivated by politics.
Any other questions?
