Where the Kids Come to Mouth Off

[Pretty Little Flower]

Originally posted by Did you just call me Coltrane?
What I meant was that it's a real language b/c it can be used for communication. Just b/c Tolkien created it out of thin air doesn't make it "fake". Samuel Morse created a language, didn't he? Morse code isn't considered a "fake" code.

Actually, I've never read any of the Rings trilogy. And I never really liked Star Trek, but this site is great: www.khaaan.com.

Your explanation is as close as I could come to giving you the benefit of the doubt. Except the Morse Code part. Morse Code is not a language because all it is is a code for English letters and then one uses that code to re-create English words with the code letters.